I had another class yesterday.
He was a tall man, lean and loose-jointed, with straggling, greenish-gray hair; a long, uneven head, broad at the skull and narrow at the chin; puffy, white bags of flabby flesh under his eyes; irregular yellow teeth and sagging cheeks that made his face look squarish. A mere boy, he had a leaden complexion, shifty gray eyes, thin lips, and an expression at once sly and conceited.
Let me quickly detach this vivid, verbose, and vile description from the possibility that it describes the male Marlborough teacher, Dr. Astorga, who taught yesterday’s seminar on “The Philosophy of Bad Taste.” It is, rather, the concluding example he left us with at the end of a very fun and comical session. It is a blurb (one of too many) in a (too-long) book called The Unwilling Vestal (underline the individual words in your mind again to indicate a book title; sorry--I'm getting a new blog tool soon).
Published in 1918, I think this book is the literature equivalent of the original Godzilla, or the objet equivalent of my treasure (photographed on today’s page): a 100% authentic, goat-hoof ashtray.
What do they all have in common? They're so bad, they're good. And the girls at Marlborough get to study this--phenomenal!
It’s part of a several-year series of short seminars (say that one 5x really fast) called Caswell Scholars. It’s completely elective, and most series are 3 sessions long, after school from 3:00 to 4:30 PM. And I think there are several session pods throughout the year, like mini-mesters.
So if you miss, for instance, “Chocolate: a Global Perspective,” or “Cell Phones, Digital Cameras, and Alarm Clocks,” “Architecture,” or “Figure Drawing,” you can pick it up in another session. At the end of the series (I don’t know how many means you’re finished), you’re a Caswell Scholar, and that designation, like other such voluntary accomplishments, can be added to your cv. Plus, you get to learn all sorts of great things. [Like you can in Wikipedia, feel free to send me corrections if I have gotten my facts wrong here.]
But, Unwilling Vestal that I am, I’m getting ahead of myself. Dr. Astorga began the lecture...(well, on my honor, I don’t really know how he began, because I was late. I was stuck in traffic and I thought, “Great, here’s the first example of really bad taste: you get a green light to sit in on a class, and you show up late.” Ugh).
In any case, there was a thorough review of the notion of "what is good" and "what is beauty," according to Plato (I've gotta say, I love Plato), and the elements that make a good plot by Aristotle.
This set the context for discussing "What do we consider bad (as in bad taste)?"
At some point, I raised my hand and asked a question about the Aristotle's notion of catharsis, and it felt so good. A cleansing of my curiosity. And ironic at the same time: to question the thing that is, itself, the question.
Oh it was all so Greek. I felt like eating a dolma.
Then, suddenly, an alien burst through the door and said to me, “Get out, you overgrown poser!”
OK, that didn’t really happen at all, but Aristotle said that a good plot usually should have peripeteia: a reversal of fortune.
By the way, on my way to being late, I was stopped in the breezeway by a spectacular-looking student who asked me if I was that lady who was going back to school. Since that is precisely who I am, I said yes; and she said her mom said to say hi. It was Lindsay Phillips, Dina and George’s 2nd daughter. Georgie and I were in school together since we were 8, and since Terrell Avazian's family long ago made me an honorary Armenian, these are totally my peeps. And now I was meeting the peeps’ middle peep. Such a cute chick: peep-peep!
And then, I told Lindsay, “Luke, I am your father.”
OK, that didn’t happen either, but it’s an example of what Aristotle eschewed: a haphazard tangent in the middle of the story; and of what he endorsed: anagnorisis, a moment in a play or other work when a character makes a critical discovery. That’s what Luke had when Darth Vader spoke that fateful line.
Oh, pass me another dolma!
So, other examples of bad taste that we explored: the multi-statued house on Mansfield & 3rd, reality shows like “John and Kate Plus Eight,” the Snuggy, The Larry David Show, King Kong, and The Orestes (please underline again--you are too good to me) by Euripides.
Eu-ripi-des, you fix-a-deese! More bad taste, more Greek humor (more dolmas, please).
Dr. Astorga covered a lot of ground, tying together the notion of bad taste, taking us from 428 BC opinion, all the way to a 2009 Mona Lisa, paint by numbers.
If we can’t all go back to school for such awesome courses, then I’m opening up my annual White Elephant Party to all alums (it used to be only locals from Class of 1981), but I’m not giving my goat-hoof ashtray up for anything in the world. (I’ll make it up to you and some make dolmas.)
Next week, we need to bring in an example of the WORST song we’ve ever heard. I’m renting Spinal Tap to prepare.
I love this school!